That is the easiest way to present how the cars really are – the Moderngranturismo main graph.
From now, will be added to each test here.
On that graph you can see two bars:
Comfort bar – tells us if the car is comfortable, quiet and suitable for 1000 km in a one day. 100% lay somewhere on the S-class level.
Sport bar – tells us how much fun that gives and how difficult to drive is it. 100% lay on the supercars. It is not about the 0-100 time or any other time, it is about fun and car behaviour.
But, at that page it is important, to stay reliable. That’s why you see:
The Moderngranturismo recommended Range:
All the cars out of range are not recommended for a Gran Turismo in the way I understand it.
Now you ask me, why the comfortable car is not suitable for Gran Turismo? That’s easy: it could be boring. For example: you have travelled 700 km to see some mountain road and you can’t push because your car doesn’t like it? Or you ask me why the supercar is not suitable for it? Because after that 700 km you are already dead because of driving uncomfortable car and you don’t have energy to push any more?
That is also very good explanation what is that page about: compromised, complete cars you can relay on. The cars you can push when you want but also the cars with the assisted driving.
If you have different priorities than me – that is no problem, you can still see on the graph how the car is and choose something for you.
Out of range doesn’t mean that aren’t good cars.
Out of range cars will still appear here, because there are different cars for different things.
As the automotive development engineer, I see the World from bit wider perspective, mainly a couple years earlier then you.
I am also the customer. With the obsessive inability to tolerate shitty solutions on cars…
Below I want to explain, my definition of the term “Complete Car” for the long-distance trips.
The nowadays cars have evolved:
from: “too much electronics”
to: “I want it so smart like my mobile”
very quickly, and most people are still on that first group. Even if they understand technical aspects, they have learnt that some… years ago.
The future could be sad…we wouldn’t drive, and we would rent instead of buying cars. But now we could enjoy being in the middle of that way!
What makes the Car Complete for me?
Most important: Driving, driving and still driving!
It must be somehow interesting. Most of time I need something fast, loud and exciting. But when I want, that has to be calm as well. Complicated compromise. That is what the modern Granturismo car has to fulfill.
Volvo or some Mercedes, are probably one of the most comfortable cars, but there will be difficult to find it here. I can’t find the place for something so calm in my garage… I have some days, when I can say, I really need it now! But I can’t buy a car for the 3 days in a year :D
I do not like Front Wheel Driven Cars, life’s too short to drive them (maybe with some exceptions). Best summer car could be RWD, all other should be 4×4 for me.
That little bit over steering, that balance in the corner, that makes me happy.
Not all of 4×4 are good enough, but there are also electronically controlled which are all right.
I’m not happy with the new BMW X1 xdrive, but I’m happy with the Mazda CX-5 drivetrain. Subaru S-AWD was my best one, but there was missing anything above it…
NCAP do it right. Also, with the electronic systems rating.
Remember there is no better way to protect people, than when there is no collision.
If you have the version without the electronic safety systems, your car is less safe then full version. That systems have saved my hood two times and that have nothing in common with that if you are a good driver or not (can the daughter of your neighbour drive? Probably not😉 ). It works. And don’t worry, hardware is also always under the investigation. 5 stars are important, and that have to be nowadays 5 stars (Remember Punto test from last year?).
Convertibles are generally not safe cars, no risk no fun!
That is the place where you spend all the time in car. It has to be fine to make you fine. Materials and design, have to be my taste. Obvious? So, tell me why Toyota sells so much cars? Nobody needs the good interiors! Only we, here! Freaks. Last year one rental gave me an Octavia (instead of Volvo, telling that is the same class!) for 3000 km (that was one of the short moments when I wanted to drive Volvo!), smallest engine, lowest trim level. I was highly disappointed, and it was hard to enjoy the trip. It was the meditation challenge: stay happy despite of travelling that…
What is interesting, despite my love to the modern solutions, I don’t like touchscreens. Good buttons are good choice in my opinion.
Imagine setting the Porsche suspension and drive mode on touchscreen…
but on the other hand I can’t wait to try new a7 to see if I’m wrong.
Infotainment, Assistance equipment
If you drive too much, and I thought if you read that, you drive too much, it is much more better when somebody is watching you. It is your IT specialist.
He drives probably better then all of us. That is fact.
Full options there makes your life and your money safer. The systems I mean are: Emergency braking Assist, Active Cruise Control, Active Line Keep Assistant, Blind Spot Assistant.
Of course, conclusion of that point is sad: it is only okay, until you can still shut him up. Completely.
I always want to drive petrol engine.
I don’t like Diesels vibrations and I miss the music of petrol exhaust.
Of course, there are the cars, where the Diesel choice is obvious, but I will rather choose smaller car with bigger petrol engine.
Not every car have to be Complete…
So, tell me now, is the 10 years old Aston Martin “Complete Car”? No. But that is not important, there is so much value according to first point (driving!) and not each car have to be complete. But still, when you don’t have Aston, it’s fine, when it is as complete as it could.
Driving the new BMW is more and more precious, fine and easier. At least until you have 40i or 40d. But the point is that, when you shut down all electronic systems, would you still have fun exactly like you want? The compromise between comfort and sport is not easy to achieve, and in my opinion the Bavarian have made that, mainly right (except the new X1). That is that factor which decides if you chose Audi, Mercedes or BMW. Depends on your taste.
The interior in the G-series is a completely new standard. The materials are much more modern and with new design looks really good.
Same as 5 Series and X3, G02 will be given Driving Assistant Plus, which keeps the distance, line and brakes itself when you make mistakes. Today the car without that systems is not more complete for me. Your safety, and your wallet safety is always good reason to invest into that option.
More about new BMW Interior standards, from 5 Series ride:
The manual gearbox is not available. Finally. If you have the grandchildren, you can start to teach them what the manual gearbox was…
If I would buy the SUV from BMW it would be that car. Stylish, big enough and at the same time not unwieldy.
That smells like the new big player and really complete car, if you want to take it on some adventure.
Update: Sitting position and first feeling:
The sitting position is slightly different then in X3. BMW makes the same trick as at first generation: The same seat from X3, but different seat positioning. And the X4 is much more my style then X3. I’ve tried sport seat and my feeling was better from the beginning. You are sitting not to high and with right angle, really comfortable, immediately ready to next hundreds of kilometres.
Sitting position at the second row is limited by the roof height. The limit lay at 175 cm passenger height, and there is enough space for knees when the driver is 180 cm. The second-row seat is comfortable and available with an angle regulation at the small range. Seat belts are also the best-known safety and comfort level.
The interior is known from the X3, and again leaved me with a good taste. Especially the wood implementation, is definitely high trim.
I have heard that X4 is more likely Mercedes than BMW now… In some way yes, it is unbelievably comfortable, but from the other hand it is still BMW DNA. Mainly with iDrive, hopefully the driving will be also typical, little bit aggressive.
Because I have been testing the BMW 5 Series G31 Touring in 520d, I want to focus on the more positive things than the basic motor. That is nothing more sad than BMW without power. There will be enough chances to talk about drivetrain of that car.
Step back: I have been driving previous generation of 5 Series last year. That was M550d at a full glory. From some reasons, I was confused: That was not really state of the art of autonomy. Interior was also not so fresh as it could be.
Do not understand me wrong, it is always f…abulous nice to drive BMW, but customers have been awaiting the new generation of automated driving. Why? Because that is the Business car and they need it to travel between Hamburg and München every week.
(I want to see Driving Assistant Plus in 1 Series, why not?)
And after 400 km, I want to be driven the next 400 km itself (and left at the end, with the energy for jogging!)
(Yes you see the TomTom there, why I need it? you can read it there:)
BMW also didn’t have the best interiors, just because that was not most important thing of the sporty car. Honestly, you forget everything around you, when the Bavarian horses starts to breathe. But nowadays… if you want to stay alive, you have to produce the complete cars…
Once I’ve said, when BMW learn how to make so fine Cockpits like “some” others, that will be big problem… for that others.
And that moment has come.
So, what I have learned in the first 600 km in new 5 Series:
New I-Drive and Infotainment: Is good. That is for sure the best Infotainment system on the market, even if 70% of the users haven’t seen 70% of the functionality. I am using 98% of it, and I really appreciate that. The main goal at the new look of the system was to tidy it a little bit up. And it is a bit different from that, what I am used to. But is still good I-drive where I have always something to do, when I want to have all the things, as I want to have it. And I do not need it as a Touchscreen (who want to clean that?).
Digital Cockpit: That works perfect. There is everything what I need on the screen. Only question is, how it would work at Convertible with sunshine on it?
Driving assistance plus: That is finally what tears me on when I am already off, because it allows you to drive longer and safer. And it is the point if you make 50 thousands kilometer per year. And that consists everything what is important: keeps the distance from others, keeps the line, brakes in emergency case alone. Try it ones, and you will never forget it.
Interior: The Interior of that BMW 5 Series is finally precious. With the Ambient light feature, works in the all conditions when it should make things easier, when you arrives to the car… with somebody else. Design is really elegant, materials are much more better and it is composed with good quality buttons. Because nobody said that everything have to be on the touchscreens.
The aim of that 2 days on the G31 with a poor motor was to discover if it is modern enough to be succesfull on the market. I have to say, it is exactly what I have awaiting from it, and it is one of the best BMW I have been driving.
You are given typical BMW driving, finally connected with nowadays features.
And there is one more gift, that platform is also available as 6 Gran Coupe. Offers more comfort and the same modern features. Well done.
PS. I have tested it in Tirol. That is unbelievable stable with xdrive, but if the things goes wrong, you realise how much that weighs! Fortunately the IT specialist have saved my wallet again…